Ding-Dong! The Witch Is Dead

So there was me assuming the 3 week international break starting in September would be dull. Not quite. This last week has been one of the most entertaining periods in football, social media, internet and probably world history. As I write, most people of a blue persuasion are still firmly entrenched in the denial stage of grief and the fallout following the verdict hasn’t even started. Going to work to witness the headloss playing out in real time is proving incredibly addictive. I’ve listened to several absurdist takes that would have been rejected by The Day Today or Brasseye for being too far fetched.

It’s safe to say, they aren’t taking it well. At all. It’s almost as if they’ve been drinking the Kool-Aid for so long that their brains are completely addled. I’ve encountered some hostility and witnessed a couple of meltdowns. This isn’t all City fans, obviously. There’s a few who are relatively normal but I think the majority have been broken by this. Despite claims to the contrary, it feels like we’ve gone back in time 30 years and dormant bitter blue genes have been reawakened. The words “red cartel” used to be the preserve of twitter lunatics but they’re now being parroted by real people who fervently believe it’s an actual thing.

Judging by the events of this last week, City fans haven’t just been lied to by their UAE sugar daddies, they’ve been fully radicalised. All football supporters are partisan by nature but the level of mental gymnastics required to disregard the overwhelming body of evidence suggests they’ve signed up to a cult. You could possibly draw some parallels with the MAGA movement or formerly placid Facebook boomers donating to Tommy Robinson and waging war on the RNLI. 

I think everyone following this long chain of events felt confident that ultimately a guilty verdict was inevitable. There were enough screenshots of emails and articles written for people to reach this conclusion within about 5 minutes. I mean, just the basic fact that MCFC went from “roughly the same size as Sheffield Wednesday” to “commercial revenue that eclipses Real Madrid” within a decade never quite added up. I know they aggressively recruited best in class but even with the greatest business brains in the world at the helm, their meteoric rise never appeared remotely plausible. 

One of the most surprising things about the whole case is that the PL actually bothered to persist with it. They’ve sat on their hands whilst all manner of nefarious owners have rocked up and rinsed English football yet all of a sudden it appears they do indeed possess a moral compass. It’s 20 years too late for MUFC, unfortunately – but better late than never. The tone of the statement released shows the extent to which they’ve grown irritated with City’s shenanigans. 5 separate uses of the word ‘sham’ suggests the PL are somewhat delighted with the verdict and are preparing to throw the book at them. 

First up though, there’s the inevitable appeal that will drag this thing out for several more months. City remain breezily confident this will all be resolved in their favour but that was to be expected – this was never going to end with a sheepish grin and an admission of guilt. Instead, they’ll continue to double-down, treble-down and quadruple-down until someone tells them what they expect to hear. The club is owned by men who’ve never heard the word ‘no’ in their lives – it’s a completely foreign concept to them. It must be mortifyingly embarrassing for the likes of Soriano who must know it’s game over yet he’s obliged to keep playing. 

There is of course the remote possibility that we’ve all missed something here and an appeal will see the verdict overturned. It might be some technicality or potentially this ‘irrefutable evidence’ they keep banging on about does actually exist. You would expect however, given the length of time this has already taken, that any such evidence has already been presented and considered. If City’s lawyers are holding some sort of trump card, fair play to them as it’ll be one of the greatest reveals of all time. If they don’t and instead it’s more of their bullshit and obfuscation, then bring on the sentencing. 

As for what form that should take, everything please. Strike the trophies from the record, massive fine, points deduction and a transfer ban for a minimum of 5 seasons. If the guilty verdict is upheld these should be the minimum sanctions given how they’ve deliberately misled the public and the authorities. Their directors and senior execs, past and present (hello Omar!) should also be banned from holding positions of administration within any sport for life. They’ve colluded to cheat, brought the game into disrepute and still to this day maintain they have nothing to apologise for. 

The ultimate punishment, after HMRC have revisited MCFC’s accounts for the years 2009-2018, would be for the newly established Independent Football Regulator (IFR) to weigh in and consider if City’s ownership meet their integrity and suitability criteria. If it’s proven they’ve inflated revenues (£830M), hidden costs (£70M), devised criminal tax avoidance schemes and committed fraud then I’d suggest not. If that’s the case then strip them of their license and force them into selling the club. 

Unfortunately, it’s unlikely that an appetite exists to take things that far. Andy Burnham flinched when the prospect was raised with him before No.10 backtracked and issued a statement reiterating that “no one is above the law”. The brutal reality is club matters are treated as state matters by the UAE government and they aren’t going to respond well to any perceived slight. Abu Dhabi isn’t just a cosy bedfellow with Manchester council, they’ve invested another £30 billion or so into the wider UK economy in the last 5 years. (We’re at the highly-mature stage of sportswashing here.)

Regardless of what happens next, the reputational damage is done. We might have always known something was off, but now the rest of the world is fully aware too. Whether the titles are stripped or not, those trophies will always have an asterisk next to them. 93:20 Aguero? Gone. MCFC broke the rules for years and cheated. Pep Guardiola is a complicit bald fraud and any journalist who’s previously claimed he’s comparable with the true managerial greats should be embarrassed. City remain comedy gold and their bootlicking “MANCHESTER THANKS YOU SHEIKH MANSOUR” support deserves all the ridicule going. This has truly been one of THE great weeks to be a United fan. 

Copyright Red News – October 2026

rednews.bigcartel.com

Stinkin’ Thinkin’

The summer is supposed to provide a window of respite from any United-related stresses. As well as giving your liver and bank balance a chance to recover, it usually means a quiet 8 weeks with no ballot deadlines to remember, no tickets to sort and no transport to organise. It’s all quite enjoyable switching off and not thinking about it for a couple of months – something the dopamine-addicted, transfer virgins on social media should try to experience at least once. 

For a large number of reds the last couple of months have been anything but stress-free if they happened to receive ‘the email’ – the club’s latest attack on ST holders and members with the usual justification of it being part of their ongoing effort to ‘combat touting’. Yeah right, of course it is. For the hundreds affected it was a case of guilty until proven innocent, with the club threatening to revoke tickets yet at the same time, choosing not to disclose what individual supporters were actually being accused of. 

It’s further evidence that the club now sees legacy supporters as a target and this latest move is proof that they’re escalating attempts to take us down. United aren’t unique in this, it’s a scenario being played out across the Premier League with mandatory digital tickets now in place across the board. In reality it just gives clubs more tools to pry into into peoples’ habits (ie how we use the ticket portals they’ve insisted on) and impose threats and sanctions under the guise of caring about supporters’ safety. What a crock of bullshit. 

The club insists that a robust appeals process is in place but given it’s now a few days from the first home game and many people are still on tenterhooks, I’m not sure it’s as solid as they claim. If supporters are logging in on multiple devices, what business is it of the club? It’s really not uncommon for people to have a desktop computer, a laptop, tablet, a couple of phones and various work devices accessible – what gives the club the right to demand explanations of how people choose to use these? It’s not just overstepping the mark, it’s completely absurd. 

In the carefully-worded, non-apology posted on the official website, the club highlighted the fact they’d uncovered an instance of a single device accessing over 1000 different accounts. Fantastic, so they’ve likely stumbled on an actual tout there – mission accomplished, you’d presume. Clearly there’s something dodgy going on in that particular case, so focus efforts there and do something about it. Using such an extreme example as justification for them accusing hundreds of others was just plain disingenuous, however. 

I’m convinced the purpose of this exercise was simply to cull a few hundred more tickets in the hope that people would react to the email by saying, “I can’t be arsed with this anymore so I’m not gonna appeal”. I’m sure they knew full well that the overwhelming number of recipients weren’t touts, but despite that they chose to send it anyway. It increases resentment, it causes upset, it creates divide. This as exactly what they want as they know full well the traditional support has no desire to embrace whatever ticketing bullshit they’re planning to introduce at their crap new stadium. 

The club has set a precedent that means this level of intrusive snooping will only continue. “You can keep your ticket for now, but be warned that we’re watching you.” Again, I simply refuse to believe that this anything to do with combatting touting – that’s just a sideshow. This is all part of a wider initiative aimed at maximising revenue from match day tickets. My ticket works out at £45 a game and the club are acutely aware that in their hands they could get 3-4 times that price if they threw in a free programme and sold it as part of a hospitality package.

ST holders might have served a purpose in previous eras providing a guaranteed steady income stream, now they’re just a nuisance with clubs looking to attract high spending football tourists instead. Like the World Cup in the summer, the Premier League has moved to a place that’s beyond commercial – it’s cynical, greedy and exploitative. They might try and spin the narrative that they’re concerned with fan safety and ticket touting (ie trying to help us), but ultimately this is about weeding us out so they can fleece bigger idiots with deeper pockets. 

With all this dominating the summer discourse there wasn’t much pre-season optimism floating about this year – which seems entirely prescient given the absolute shitshow served up at Hull. I was hoping we might avoid being 7 points behind in September for once, but based on Saturday’s evidence that might be wishful thinking. Honestly, I don’t know where to start. Sloth-like movement, players not looking fit, complete failure to press and once again, an entire team seemingly shocked and stunned by the intensity of the PL. 

I was quite enthused by the Tielemans signing but the guy looks woefully out of shape and even slower than Casemiro. Santos was slightly better but I still can’t help thinking we’ve not really plugged any of the holes that were evident last season. Baleba is an apparent done dealio and is going to have to do a lot of heavy lifting over the coming months. A lot of the conversation has been about needing a new LB this summer, but Mazraoui had another terrible game on the opposite flank. It demonstrates just how bad United were when I’m stood there pining for Dalot to be brought on after half an hour. 

To cap it all, there’re still no takers for Marcus Rashford. I’m praying something happens over the next week or so otherwise this current marriage of inconvenience will likely end in disaster. The club doesn’t want him and he doesn’t want to be here either. It says everything about him that he’s literally putting money ahead of his career by insisting on seeing out this contract. There’s been lots of good work done in weeding out corrosive figures in United’s dressing room, this shouldn’t be jeopardised by giving a fresh opportunity to someone who burnt his bridges a long time ago. 

Copyright Red News – August 2026

rednews.bigcartel.com

Don’t Look Back

With the absence of European football there was hope we might see more Saturday 3pms this year but we appear to have become Monday night mainstays instead. Not great for anyone travelling long distances, not great for fanzine sales and especially not great for those of us whose ideal match day is typically bookended by 5-6 hours ‘socialising’. I’ve not added it up but compared to last season’s total outlay I must’ve saved an absolute fortune.

Thanks to Michael Carrick and the general ineptitude of rival teams, at the time of writing it looks like CL qualification will be secured with games to spare. We’ve only played once over the last month and yet we’re still in 3rd place somehow – it’ll take an almighty capitulation for us to balls it up now. It’s been quite the turnaround from 12 months ago where despite lurching all the way to Bilbao, a 15th place finish was exactly what we deserved after an appallingly poor PL campaign. 

This season has been much improved, particularly in the period immediately after Carrick’s appointment where Mainoo returned to the starting line-up and the whole team started to play like the shackles were off. We’re still quite brittle, particularly at OT (as Leeds recently demonstrated) but the positive signs are starting to outweigh the negatives (he said tentatively). The game at Stamford Bridge serves as a good example of this as there’s no way we would have seen that out so comfortably under Amorim. 

Our inconsistency at home is made plain if you consider the experience of my mate’s 14 year old daughter. She’s been coming to the game with us over the last 3-4 years whenever there’s a spare ticket. Last season we noticed a trend had developed and after some discussion and questioning, it came to light that in 25+ visits to OT she’s seen United win a grand total of ONCE. It’s an incredible stat which has now led to her being known as ‘the curse’. If this poor girl had been born 2 decades previously she’d more than likely have never seen us get beat. 

I was one of those people banging on about the missed opportunity for an unlikely title charge bearing in mind the horrendous run of dropped points over Christmas. A mate then helpfully pointed out that if we’d won those games (Everton, West Ham, Bournemouth & Wolves) then the likelihood is Amorim would never have been sacked in the first place. Instead of anticipating the return of CL football, we’d still be stuck in mid-table and Kobbie Mainoo would be about to leave for Napoli or wherever. 

As usual, the upcoming summer transfer window is going to be key as regards how we progress from here. Prior to that, you’d hope they’ll make a decision within the next couple of weeks on Michael Carrick’s immediate future. All things considered, I wouldn’t have any issue with him getting the gig full-time as I think he’s done pretty well. Judging by the body language, the players appear to be fully on-board and results have been decent overall. If he finishes top four and doesn’t get the job then he’ll have every right to feel a bit aggrieved. 

The main priority in the summer has to be replacing Casemiro with someone of a similar calibre, yet minus the ageing legs. Casemiro has been very good this last few months playing in tandem with Kobbie. He’s a top professional and will be remembered fondly for his efforts during what’s been a turbulent 4 year stay at the club. Clearly, he’s benefited from the less-congested fixture calendar this season as there’s no way he can handle playing twice a week at this stage of his career. 

Casimero’s imminent departure wouldn’t seem so dramatic if we had someone capable of filling his boots, but Ugarte has been mostly terrible when called upon and will likely follow him out of the door. That leaves Bruno, Kobbie, the perma-injured Mount and a bunch of kids with a handful of first team appearances between them. Amorim explained last summer that we could manage with a depleted squad due to not playing in Europe but that won’t be the case next season. 

Aside from that, the priority is probably a right back but given budgetary constraints I’d be content with a couple of new midfielders. 12 months ago I’d have been happy to cash in on Bruno but he’s responded with his best season since he was at the peak of his powers during Covid. He’s possibly in with a shout of winning the PFA award as I don’t really see many other standout candidates. City will probably end up edging out Arsenal to win the league but both teams are nowhere near the level they were a couple of years ago. 

This summer will thankfully see us rid of Jadon Sancho, an absolute disaster of a signing whose career continues its steady decline. Neither Villa nor Chelsea wanted him on a permanent deal so he’ll likely opt for another shot at Dortmund – the only place on earth where he seems capable of getting his act together. There are numerous cases of modern pros thinking they’ve made it at 21 with nothing left to prove, post-Fergie MUFC have certainly been good at cultivating them. 

Another one too thick to understand how lucky he actually was, is our friend Alejandro Garnacho. This brainiac has gone from an out-of-sorts, inconsistent mess at United to an out-of-sorts, inconsistent mess at Chelsea where everyone hates him.  Those “we’ll have him for 3-4 years then he’ll go to Madrid” predictions seem a very long time ago now. All because he got dropped to the bench for the Europa final and responded with a complete hissy fit. He’ll get forced out there, do 2 years at Villarreal and then head ‘home’ to South America. In other words, the Anthony Martial career trajectory. 

Talking of inconsistency, I’m not in the least bit surprised to learn that Marcus Rashford’s ‘dream move’ to Barca might be coming to swift conclusion. Due to a supportive fanbase and an effective PR team, he was given an easy ride here despite years of erratic performances. Instead of accepting some criticism as merely part of the job, the sense of entitlement grew and he’d completely lost the plot by the time he was shipped off to Villa. Keep your fingers crossed the club isn’t considering offering him an olive branch. Enjoy the summer and I’ll see you in August. 

Copyright Red News – May 2026

rednews.bigcartel.com